Happy Valley by Benjamin Moore is the closest match from any other brand (near-identical), and it keeps Cocoa Butter’s lightness, warmth and saturation. The closest value-tier option is Shiny Silk by Johnstone's (near-identical), just as true to the original. 14 of the 19 other brands have a near-identical match. LRV is estimated from each brand’s swatch, so order testers before committing.
One brand can appear several times if it has more than one close match. For the single best match per brand, see the Cocoa Butter colour page.
All 20 close matches, ranked
The number on each is how far apart the two colours are: under 2 is near-identical, under 5 very close. How it’s worked out.
18Honey HarborBenjamin Moore · Premium · near-identical · 1.7Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Cocoa Butter.#F1E4C4
19Barely ButterJohnstone's · Value · near-identical · 1.7Darker (about 3 LRV points) than Cocoa Butter.#F1E3BE
20Clay IIIPaint & Paper Library · Premium · near-identical · 1.8Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Cocoa Butter.#EFE5C7
Common questions
Is there a Dulux equivalent to Cocoa Butter?
The nearest Dulux colour is Cornish Cream (near-identical). It won’t be pixel-perfect, so order a tester before committing.
What’s the best-value alternative to Cocoa Butter?
Of the close matches, Shiny Silk by Johnstone's is the best-value option (value, near-identical).
How close are these to Cocoa Butter?
They’re ranked nearest first by perceptual colour difference, and the label on each card says how close it is. Screens differ from paint on a wall, so treat these as a shortlist and order tester pots.
Matching a different colour?
Search any paint name in the tool to see its closest matches across all twenty brands.