Parasol by Paint & Paper Library is the closest match from any other brand (near-identical), and it keeps Butterball’s lightness, warmth and saturation. The closest value-tier option is Maybe Maui by Johnstone's (very close), lighter (about 4 LRV points). 7 of the 19 other brands have a near-identical match. LRV is estimated from each brand’s swatch, so order testers before committing.
One brand can appear several times if it has more than one close match. For the single best match per brand, see the Butterball colour page.
All 20 close matches, ranked
The number on each is how far apart the two colours are: under 2 is near-identical, under 5 very close. How it’s worked out.
3York Harbor YellowBenjamin Moore · Premium · near-identical · 1.9#EAC17C
4Pale CreamDulux Heritage · Premium · very close · 2.4Slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterball.#E5C586
5Sun Dust 3Dulux · Mid-range · very close · 2.6Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butterball.#EABE73
6Maybe MauiJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.6Lighter (about 4 LRV points) than Butterball.Closest match from a value-tier brand.#ECC985
7Golden SquareMylands · Premium · very close · 2.7Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butterball.#F1C476
8WaxTikkurila · Premium · very close · 2.7Darker (about 3 LRV points) than Butterball.#E2BE7C
9Beehive PlaceMylands · Premium · very close · 2.9Slightly softer than Butterball.#E4C685
10Desert Island 4Dulux · Mid-range · very close · 3.3Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butterball.#EDC687
11Beverly HillsBenjamin Moore · Premium · very close · 3.3Noticeably lighter (about 5 LRV points) than Butterball.#F1CA7F
12GoldfinchBenjamin Moore · Premium · very close · 3.5Slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterball.#E5C48B
13Desert Island 3Dulux · Mid-range · very close · 3.5#F1C278
14Golden TanBenjamin Moore · Premium · very close · 3.7Slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterball.#E0C389
15Mustard JarCrown · Mid-range · very close · 3.8Darker (about 3 LRV points), slightly warmer and slightly more saturated than Butterball.#E7BD67
16Ciara YellowFarrow & Ball · Premium · very close · 3.9Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butterball.#DFC380
17Modern NudeTikkurila · Premium · very close · 3.9Noticeably darker (about 5 LRV points) than Butterball.#DEBC76
18Yellow GroundFarrow & Ball · Premium · very close · 4.0Noticeably lighter (about 5 LRV points) than Butterball.#EDCC8A
19DijonBenjamin Moore · Premium · very close · 4.1Noticeably cooler and noticeably softer than Butterball.#E1C28B
20SorrentoLakeland Paints · Mid-range · very close · 4.1Slightly warmer and slightly more saturated than Butterball.#F1BF6A
Common questions
Is there a Dulux equivalent to Butterball?
The nearest Dulux colour is Sun Dust 3 (very close). It won’t be pixel-perfect, so order a tester before committing.
What’s the best-value alternative to Butterball?
Of the close matches, Maybe Maui by Johnstone's is the best-value option (value, very close).
How close are these to Butterball?
They’re ranked nearest first by perceptual colour difference, and the label on each card says how close it is. Screens differ from paint on a wall, so treat these as a shortlist and order tester pots.
Matching a different colour?
Search any paint name in the tool to see its closest matches across all twenty brands.