Wet Sand by Farrow & Ball is the closest match from any other brand (very close), and it keeps Butterscotch Sundae’s lightness, warmth and saturation. The closest value-tier option is Pumpkin Patch by Johnstone's (very close), just as true to the original. 2 of the 19 other brands have a near-identical match. LRV is estimated from each brand’s swatch, so order testers before committing.
One brand can appear several times if it has more than one close match. For the single best match per brand, see the Butterscotch Sundae colour page.
All 20 close matches, ranked
The number on each is how far apart the two colours are: under 2 is near-identical, under 5 very close. How it’s worked out.
1Wet SandFarrow & Ball · Premium · very close · 2.5Closest overall match.#BD8C5F
2Pumpkin PatchJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.7Closest match from a value-tier brand.#C4885C
3Root GingerJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.8Slightly warmer and slightly more saturated than Butterscotch Sundae.#C1864E
4Peanut ButterDulux · Mid-range · very close · 3.0Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butterscotch Sundae.#BF8E63
5Butterscotch FrostJohnstone's · Value · very close · 3.5Darker (about 2 LRV points), slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#B5845F
6BroomstickJohnstone's · Value · very close · 3.9Darker (about 3 LRV points) than Butterscotch Sundae.#B58050
7ScapegoatTikkurila · Premium · very close · 4.3Slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#B68D66
8Raw AmberFired Earth · Premium · very close · 4.4Lighter (about 3 LRV points) and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#BC9066
9BeeswaxTikkurila · Premium · very close · 4.4Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butterscotch Sundae.#BE8D59
10Bronze StormValspar · Value · very close · 4.7Darker (about 4 LRV points) than Butterscotch Sundae.#B57D51
11SalmonLakeland Paints · Mid-range · very close · 4.8#C0845F
12Hitching PostJohnstone's · Value · very close · 4.8Darker (about 3 LRV points), slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#B38260
13Proud StagJohnstone's · Value · close · 5.0Lighter (about 3 LRV points), slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#BA916B
14Cinnamon SconeValspar · Value · close · 5.3Noticeably cooler and noticeably softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#B48C6E
15Pinch of CloveValspar · Value · close · 5.3Lighter (about 2 LRV points) and slightly more saturated than Butterscotch Sundae.#CB875A
17Nectar Jewels 2Dulux · Mid-range · close · 5.9Slightly more saturated than Butterscotch Sundae.#CD8555
18Polo CoatFired Earth · Premium · close · 5.9Noticeably lighter (about 5 LRV points), slightly cooler and slightly softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#C5946E
19Caramel MuffinJohnstone's · Value · close · 6.0Slightly warmer than Butterscotch Sundae.#BE8B4F
20Tropical TanJohnstone's · Value · close · 6.1Darker (about 3 LRV points), slightly cooler and noticeably softer than Butterscotch Sundae.#AB845E
Common questions
Is there a Dulux equivalent to Butterscotch Sundae?
The nearest Dulux colour is Peanut Butter (very close). It won’t be pixel-perfect, so order a tester before committing.
What’s the best-value alternative to Butterscotch Sundae?
Of the close matches, Pumpkin Patch by Johnstone's is the best-value option (value, very close).
How close are these to Butterscotch Sundae?
They’re ranked nearest first by perceptual colour difference, and the label on each card says how close it is. Screens differ from paint on a wall, so treat these as a shortlist and order tester pots.
Matching a different colour?
Search any paint name in the tool to see its closest matches across all twenty brands.