Benjamin Moore Butter Cookie alternatives

The colour you’re matching
Benjamin Moore Butter Cookie
Hex#E9E0C0LRV≈ 74ShadePale cream

PaintDial verdict

Jurassic Coast by Johnstone's is the closest match from any other brand (near-identical), and it keeps Butter Cookie’s lightness, warmth and saturation. It’s also the best-value tier among the close matches, which is unusual: normally the nearest and the best-value match are different paints. 14 of the 19 other brands have a near-identical match. LRV is estimated from each brand’s swatch, so order testers before committing.

One brand can appear several times if it has more than one close match. For the single best match per brand, see the Butter Cookie colour page.

All 20 close matches, ranked

The number on each is how far apart the two colours are: under 2 is near-identical, under 5 very close. How it’s worked out.

1Jurassic CoastJohnstone's · Value · near-identical · 0.5Closest overall match.#E9E0C2
2SoleilJohnstone's · Value · near-identical · 0.5#E9E0C2
3White OchreFired Earth · Premium · near-identical · 0.9#E7DEBF
4VanillaLakeland Paints · Mid-range · near-identical · 1.2#E6DFBE
5Cashmere IVPaint & Paper Library · Premium · near-identical · 1.5#EAE1C6
6AprilTikkurila · Premium · near-identical · 1.5#E5DFC3
7Subtle GlowValspar · Value · near-identical · 1.5#ECDFBD
8CreamZoffany · Premium · near-identical · 1.9Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E9DDB8
9Silent White - DeepLittle Greene · Premium · near-identical · 1.9Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#EBE3C8
10NeutralSanderson · Premium · near-identical · 2.0Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E5DEC5
11La PlageZoffany · Premium · very close · 2.0Lighter (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#EFE2BE
12Jasper YellowCraig & Rose · Premium · very close · 2.0Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E6DDB8
13Cavendish CreamMylands · Premium · very close · 2.1Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E9DCBB
14Pale ParchmentSanderson · Premium · very close · 2.1#EADDBF
15Natural VanillaJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.1Darker (about 2 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E9DCBC
16Spot OnTikkurila · Premium · very close · 2.1#EBDEB7
17Slices Of HappyJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.1#E7DFB8
18SausalitoJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.2#EDDFC0
19CreamJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.2Darker (about 3 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#E6DBBD
20Maiden HairJohnstone's · Value · very close · 2.3Lighter (about 3 LRV points) than Butter Cookie.#EEE4C7

Common questions

Is there a Dulux equivalent to Butter Cookie?

The nearest Dulux colour is Celtic Forest 5 (very close). It won’t be pixel-perfect, so order a tester before committing.

What’s the best-value alternative to Butter Cookie?

Of the close matches, Jurassic Coast by Johnstone's is the best-value option (value, near-identical).

How close are these to Butter Cookie?

They’re ranked nearest first by perceptual colour difference, and the label on each card says how close it is. Screens differ from paint on a wall, so treat these as a shortlist and order tester pots.

Matching a different colour?

Search any paint name in the tool to see its closest matches across all twenty brands.

See the full Butter Cookie colour page →

If you found PaintDial useful…

Buy Will a coffee on Ko-fi