Sheldon by COAT is the closest match from any other brand (near-identical), and it keeps Brown Tar’s lightness, warmth and saturation. The closest value-tier option is Aged Cognac by Valspar (near-identical), just as true to the original. 5 of the 19 other brands have a near-identical match. LRV is estimated from each brand’s swatch, so order testers before committing.
One brand can appear several times if it has more than one close match. For the single best match per brand, see the Brown Tar colour page.
All 20 close matches, ranked
The number on each is how far apart the two colours are: under 2 is near-identical, under 5 very close. How it’s worked out.
12Château MantleValspar · Value · very close · 3.0Slightly warmer than Brown Tar.#74573C
13Earth Glaze 1Dulux · Mid-range · very close · 3.1#6B5137
14Golden Bark 1Dulux · Mid-range · very close · 3.2#6A4E36
15Polished BuckeyeValspar · Value · very close · 3.3Slightly softer than Brown Tar.#6A5948
16MochaJohnstone's · Value · very close · 3.7Slightly softer than Brown Tar.#6A5A4A
17Tampico BrownJohnstone's · Value · very close · 3.7Slightly warmer and slightly more saturated than Brown Tar.#734E36
18Ratty's ReturnLakeland Paints · Mid-range · very close · 3.8#65503B
19BreweryJohnstone's · Value · very close · 3.8#684F36
20ChocolatLakeland Paints · Mid-range · very close · 3.9Slightly cooler and slightly softer than Brown Tar.#635448
Common questions
Is there a Dulux equivalent to Brown Tar?
The nearest Dulux colour is Rich Praline 2 (near-identical). It won’t be pixel-perfect, so order a tester before committing.
What’s the best-value alternative to Brown Tar?
Of the close matches, Aged Cognac by Valspar is the best-value option (value, near-identical).
How close are these to Brown Tar?
They’re ranked nearest first by perceptual colour difference, and the label on each card says how close it is. Screens differ from paint on a wall, so treat these as a shortlist and order tester pots.
Matching a different colour?
Search any paint name in the tool to see its closest matches across all twenty brands.